Richard & Phyllis Kay
Age: 60+
Occupation:Retired
Number of Cruises: 18
Cruise Line: Norwegian
Ship: Norwegian Star
Sailing Date: December 19th, 2005
Itinerary: Mexican Riveria
Norwegian Cruise Line
Norwegian Star Cruise Review
Mexican Riveria
Richard and Phyllis Kay
My wife and I have literally cruised all over the world from freighters to Vista
class ships. The past five years our family of six has been cruising the Mexican
Riveria (because of vacation time available for our fourteen year old
granddaughter.) Our children had never been to Acapulco or Xtapa, and we
purposely booked an eight day cruise (Dec. 19.05) on NCL's
Norwegian Star) going to the new ports.
Practically the only difference
in a negative review by a Newitt Bradley who booked the Dec/ 3/05 cruise was
that passengers waiting in line to board for an hour and a half were notified in
line of the change due to mechanical difficulties by a flyer passed out by
attendants. Upon our return I immediately wrote the President of NCL enumerating
the problems. To date the only answer I have received is a standard printed post
card sent on Dec. 4,2006 that my letter was received and they were looking into
it. It is now January 27, 2006 and I have received no further correspondence.
However, my son did in-form me that he received a letter from an attorney
regarding a class action suit" that has evidentially been filed against NCL. It
is hard for me to believe that NCL changed the itinerary because the mechanical
difficulties limited the cruising ability to no more than 20 knots. However, we
have pictures (taken from the cabin TV that on several occasions the ship was
cruising faster than 2; knots. It was the opinion of the majority of th e
passengers that since Acapulco was an additional six hundred miles the fuel
costs would cut into the huge profit NCL recently released in a Jan. news item.
We always book a handicapped room due to my needing the use of an electric
scooter - and are used to a large room with a great deal of closet and drawer
space (as we are used to on the HAL's Ryndam) Instead we were in a cabin barely
large enough to accommodate my scooter. One small closet, and three small
drawers in a desk to accommodate our belongings. Mr. Bradley (not in a handi-capped
also commented on the small accommodations. The first full day of sailing, the
reception area was crowded with passengers complaining about the change in
itinerary, and other problems prevalent aboard. Example: our cabin was not
cleaned until my wife notified housekeeping. The only good service was - room
service which came promptly when called - that is when we could get the
telephone to work properly. Mr. Bradley, upon receiving his bar bill asked the
bartender about the 15% gratuity automatically put on the bill. He was in-formed
that the crew DID NOT of the automatic gratuities placed on our final bill. On
two occasions we took our party of six to the cover charge restaurants, because
the food in the "no charge" restaurants we liter-ally inedible. In addition to
the cover charge if you wished a surf bad turf you were charged an ADDITIONAL
$25.00. The standard joke among the passengers was what you didn't eat at dinner
the night before you gotten some inedible form the next day for lunch. Our
travel agent always send a bottle of wine to our cabin (never received.)
Since we usually book well in advance to make certain we get a handicapped cabin
= we received no cabin upgrade - but my agent always makes certain we receive a
$50.00 gift credit for each cabin - am item listed on our ticket, but when my
wife complained to the reception desk we were told that the $50.00 was a gift
from our travel agent. Adding insult to injury NCL magnanimously gave each cabin
$100.00 credit for the change in itinerary. This is really an insult after
reading of the "mutiny of the passengers on the Queen Mary 2" They received full
reimbursement of their tickets AND airfare. A major problem aboard was lack of
communication between passengers and crew. An example of not being able to
understand them was the fact that my fourteen year old granddaughter ordered a
virgin margarita - and was served a drink with alcohol in it. I have just
torched on the major points that made our cruise a grave dis-appointment but I
will end with a closing statement by Mr. Bradley which stated that his first
cruise would be his LAST on NCL. Our family definitely concurs - in fact our
travel agent is already working on our nest cruise (fifteen days to Hawaii)
which will NOT be with NCL. Closing on a bit of humor. When we were moored in
Cabo - the Ryndan was moored next to us. The consensus of our family's opinion
we should don water wings - get our luggage - and swim over to the Ryndam to
enjoy the rest of the voyage.