I agree that it is all subjective… There are some people that cruise because they want to be pampered so those need the suite life and all that comes with it... there are others that don’t care as long as they are on a ship.
Obviously RCCL has at least up to this point please you and your family or I don’t think you would have returned to sail with them again and again.
If you just want to try a different brand so you can compare. Then you will indeed find more opinions then there are cruise ships.
Bottom Line IMHO is decide what works for you then go for it.. research research research… Good luck!
"Integrity begins with I!"