Not much help on the cabins Jim. I assume you're talking about the corner afts. We have a friend that always books those cabins. They absolutely love them. I believe they even have a pole in the middle of the room. I do seem to remember them saying that the room is wider and shorter.
We had a corner aft on Liberty, deck 7 and it was fantastic. Huge balcony and it also had the big circular opening on the side. It also had plenty of shade and or sunshine and lot's of privacy from the side or above.
I'm kinda like you about the "sign" on the side. Look at it this way, once onboard, we don't have to look at it.
Celebrity Eclipse March 5, 2011
Serenade of the Seas Oct 23, 2011