Thank you both for the info. As I do more research, I am starting to notice that there isn't much of a diference in private tour prices from Carnival prices. Either Carnival has gone down or private tour prices have gone up?
Either way I think I will check on St. John's. I have heard so many great things. Funny thing is that I don't remember seeing any tours with Carnival that go to St. Johns. I will have to double check.