Hi Larry and others posting here. Since you have not recieved a response from any past pax I'll give you my two cents worth. Liberty is only 2 1/2 years old and as some know, I get reports back regularly from pax from many ships. Liberty and Freedom are the two ships with consistantly the highest reviews in CCL fleet. I get rave reviews on food, service, staff and other aspects. Of couse there are many reviews on here as well and although I havent read through them I'm confident they will reflect the same views I get. I just checked my own bookings for a 90 day period and have over 85% exceded expectations ratings for Liberty. With the number of folks out there that will complain about anything and everything that's a truely impressive number. Have a great cruise and give us your own review when you return.