Very good point Dave, I didn't realize there was any confusion. Auto-tipping is common and the way I normally take care of them, a little extra if someone was exceptional along with what they hit. If someone is less than exceptional I have even requested that persons tips be given to the exceptional person instead. They assured me it would be done but I have no way of knowing for sure and suspect they still give per the schedule provided. Still made me feel like justice onboard is alive.