We were there in December. We did the excursion to Trunk Bay and were very pleased with it. We did the afternoon one which was not as crowded.
We particularly liked the snorkel trip to Pineel Island at St. Martin. Walter was a big help to first time snorkelers.
We went to Dickinson Beach at Antigua on our own. We got there at 9:30 am and were the only ones there for 1 1/2 hrs. Loved the feel of the sand and clear water. Do watch out for jelly fish.
We did the Souffreie(sp)excursion at St. Lucia. 5 1/2 hrs was well worth the time and money.
We heard raves about the turtle snorkeling trip at Barbados. We just went to Boat Yard Beach and had a great time. That was the clearest and best water of the whole trip.