Welcome to Cruise Reviews!
I don't publicly comment about the members of other forums. I do think every cruise line has it's share of rabid fans who do not accept any criticism, and some are more annoying about it than others. There was a media flap a few years ago about a group of 'royal commanders' at that forum. I think it ended up costing a Royal Caribbean executive their job.
As for those negative reviews...most of them are submitted by people with an axe to grind because of some little issue that stuck in their craw. Sort of like someone who doesn't like excessive use of metaphors writing a review of my post!