I passed on all the info and suggestions you've given me. I feel badly if I gave the impression that I was attempting to travel with a bunch of cruise-snobs; that's so not true. Everyone in the group has cruised before, with the exception of my immediate family, so they have more insight than I do. We can all agree that it's the Caribbean we want, but we're limited with choices leaving out of NYC in July. In fact the only 2 Caribbean choices are Carnival, and RCL with leaves from Port Liberty in NJ. NCL's Dawn goes to Bermuda only. So our options are slim, and the price difference between them considerable. We're not looking for a big luxury cruise, just a good time on a nice ship.
I have encouraged one and all to take advantage of this terrific site. The amount of info here is incredible. Thanks again!