I'm torn between the eastern caribbean sailings of the Navigator and the Mariner. What I'm hoping will be the dealbreaker is the excursions. I don't like to do them on my own, I like the adventure ones that I can just book without having to think too much about it. Like, is horseback riding in San Juan and stingray snorkeling and the sub bahama adventure in Nassau better than the waverunners and snorkeling in CocoCay?
While I'm on the topic, is the ATVing on St. Maarten and the deep sea helmet dive on Charlotte Amalie worth it? What excursions has everyone enjoyed on these iteneraries? I'd love to know and it would really help me..