View Single Post
  #1 (permalink)  
Old 07-03-2007, 10:28 AM
gdjoslin's Avatar
gdjoslin gdjoslin is offline
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Near Yosemite, California
Posts: 1,937
Zaandam v Carnival Spirit/Pride v Sun Princess.

We are a semi-retired couple of 56 and 59 years. We have cruised on Carnival 3 times, twice on the Pride and once on the Spirit. Carnival cruises were all to Mexico in the last 3 or 4 years. We have cruised on the Sun Princess once, last year to The Alaskan Inside Passage. This Cruise on the Zaandam was to the Alaskan Inside Passage.

Rooms: Spirit/Pride has the biggest room, followed close by the Zaandam with the Sun Princess bringing up the rear. My wife says Hal has more storage space, but it is a little tighter.

Ships spaces: Generally we found the Princess needed more. The Spirit/Pride had plenty, but the Zaandam takes the prize here. There is seating every where. My wife’s favorite was the Crows Nest. It is located on Deck 9 on the bow. The views from here are breath taking.

Food: We generally eat on the lido deck very seldom. However the Spirit/pride would take it here. Their food is hot and served quickly, seating is easier to find. Seating on the Sun and Zaandam were next to impossible to find. Food on the Sun was hot, not so on the Zaandam. (By the way I grew up on buffet food, my parents owned a buffet. I know what hot fresh food is.) The Sun is faster than the Zaandam in serving; the Zaandam just needs a couple more servers. An example of this is the Omelets. On the Spirit and Sun the cook preparing dishes for 3-4 people at a time. On the Zaandam the cook had 3 skillets not in use, he just worked on one omelet at a time, and this slowed the line to a crawl!!

The main dining Room I will give to the Spirit again Good service, better Choices, and HOT food and cold salads. The Sun would be second as it was very close to the Spirit. The Zaandam served cool food and limp salads. The server was great, but the food was poor. The three cuts of meat I had were all tough and chewy. Never had anything like that before on a cruise ship.

The bar servers (we drink Coke) were great on the Spirit and the Sun. After the first night our sodas were had the table. The Zaandam’s server was different every night he would try to serve us a drink or wine. We would tell him we wanted a soda, and we would see him about half a meal later.

Cabin Steward. Sun and Spirit was great, friendly fast service, never a problem. The Zaandam was poor. We were not serviced on the first day and the 5th day... until we called and requested it after our evening meal. The service the rest of the time was very poor. My wife had a soda glass with about a ½ inch in the glass. It was there 6 days before we removed it.

Other thoughts. Our cabin toilet was broken. It worked off and on (mostly off) for the first 5 days. I felt they could have fixed it quicker. We had requested a table to two. We got a table for six. It was very hard to get changed.

We always tip extra to those that serve us. Only the Waiter on the Zaandam got extra. We were really tempted to reduce the amounts we paid to the Cabin Steward but did not.

We plan on taking another HAL Cruise sometime. We are hoping the food and the service we received are not the norm.

We usually buy soda cards. They are not worth it on Hal. On Carnival and Princess the card is good for unlimited drinks. On Hal it is good for 20 small glass of soda. It is cheaper to buy the soda by the card on HAL.

Questions? Please ask.
Cruise Photos from Mexico and Alaska