This question basically is asking for an opinion and here it is based on the cruise lines we've tried. They are listed in the order we would rate them:
#1) Celebrity--based on 2 cruises
#2) Holland America--based on 6 cruises
#3) Carnival--based on 3 cruises
#4) Royal Caribbean--based on 1 cruise
#5) Norwegian--based on 1 cruise
HAL was our favorite, however we think they slipped a notch since they went to auto tipping. Their service spoiled us on the first 5. Norwegian was our last cruise and we may try Princess next. All cruises have been good, with a few very good, and we have not had a bad cruise.
Keith & Rita Ann
Fast dancing is the second best form of exercise,
slow dancing leads to the first!