Let me add that we've never used the specialty restaurants (I won't include Johnny Rockets even though it costs a little extra). I have been one who felt as the others do - that the included food in the dining rooms was paid for and why should I be hit with extra charges for a steak.
But things change and I realize that I might be missing something. So I think we will try it the next time we are on a ship with these places. Unfortunately that does not include our upcoming cruise, since the Rhapsody has not been refitted with a Chops.