We went to Cozumel last year and did Paradise Beach. We were the first ones there, and it was so nice! The water was warm, the bar was nearby, and it was an all around excellent time. I suggest the Sols in a bucket.
I'd love to go back to PB someday! In less than 2 weeks I'll be in Tortola, San Juan, St. Thomas, St. Maarten, and Great Stirrup Cay! SO EXCITED!!!