What tipped the scales for you, deputy?
Carnival ships have always sort of seemed quite similar to me -- just the decor is different.
What has made the difference for me has been crew members or bands, things like that. For instance, our last cruise, which was on the Spirit, had a very good band in one of the dance clubs, and the very best karaoke host we've EVER had on any ship. On the other hand, the pianist at the piano bar, and the Maitre'd were among the worst.