How about all of them

I'd probably pick the Imagination because I love Key West and Cozumel. Now if they'd pair, Grand Cayman and Key West, that would be awesome. The only problem with Grand Cayman is tendering. If the seas are rough, you can't take the tenders in. It doesn't happen often, but it does happen. Out of 6 visits to Grand Cayman, twice we couldn't get in, so it's pretty good odds that you can. I used to love Freeport, but everyone has said it's gone downhill badly. I've always enjoyed Nassau, so like I said-all of them