tncruiseman I was to both in November and absolutely loved it! Grand Turks was raining so that was a bummer but Half Moon Cay was gorgeous!!!
If you have never seen Paradise that's where it is. The most beautiful water I have ever seen. I could have stayed forever...well maybe only till I had shopping withdrawls. I have heard averything from one person lives on the island to 40 people live on the island. Looked like nice apartments in the back so I am betting more than one lives there.