Hi LouisianaLee, welcome to Cruise-Chat! I am so glad to hear you're planning another cruise after your 4 day Cozumel cruise
Sounds like we have another addict on board
Like Dwayne said, Key West is the ultimate walking around port. I'm going back to Freeport in a few months after a long, long lapse in visits, so I can let you know the condition when I return. I have heard reports that it has gone to the dogs, but I want to see for myself. Nassau has the straw market near the pier and you can hop in a cab and go to Atlantis, there is a free beach adjacent to Atlantis, Cabbage Beach, that is quite nice. Montego Bay, you will want to either get a day pass to an all-inclusive or take a ship's tour. Jamaica is beautiful, but poor, and not a place to walk around on your own. Grand Cayman is a nice, clean island. You can walk around the shops right near where the tender docks. There's a dive shop that will let you go into the water for some great snorkeling. And you can catch a cab and go to 7 mile beach, which is absolutely gorgeous. Cozumel you know about, but we rented a scooter the last time we were there and had a ball. We stopped at all the different beaches, then went around the south end and started back up when the rains came. We will finish our route the next time we go back. Both itineraries are great. To get real Caribbean beaches, Cozumel, Jamaica and Grand Cayman will give you a great taste. Now, if you want to go to St. Thomas and take the ferry over to Trunk Bay, you'll see one of the top 10 beaches in the world!
Have fun selecting your cruise and let us know what y'all decide!