i have been on the fantasy and the holiday both before and after. the fantasy was great,mostly cosmetic,but i think they are going to add the water works(the slide)later.the holiday was a smaller refurb.it was after the people from katrina got dowm with her.again mostly cosmetic with a putt putt golf. she is leaving to spain in the fall.
We have been on the Imagination and the Fantasy since the Evolutions of Fun was added.
The Imagination (January of 2008) was a brand new ship.
The Fantasy used a different shipyard and it really struggled. It did add the new "stuff" (having sailed it many times before and after the re-do) and EVENTUALLY it was ok....but not the WOW brand new factor we experienced on the Imagination...and that was a disappointment.
Obviously not a big enough disappointment to stop us from cruising on her - 4 times since the refit....but disappointing none the less.