Celebrity compared with Princess ???

[Tony 'Dusty' Graber]

Hi,

I've done two Celebrity (Mercury and Infinity) (and I did Carnival Victory before that).
While the ships were different, interesting, I enjoyed them, but the food (especially dinners) on Celebrity was definitely better.
I'm planning the next cruise and we will be joined by my Mom and two brothers (all first time cruisers).
I do my homework, and am looking at the Star Princess (the Grand/Golden class) or a Royal Caribbean Voyager Class.
MY QUESTION is the food quality. You eat on the ship all week, I enjoy above average food (especially at dinner). Realizing Celebrity is noted for that, how about the other two ... again Star Princess or a Voyager Class (Royal Carribean) ???
I'm familiar with the other features, and would like one of these ... I'm just hoping not to be disappointed by the food quality (and while not bad, I thought Carnival was OK, just nothing great, wonderful, or memorable).
Please be a little specific. Thanks.

[Raoul Fiebig]

Tony,

please continue in your original thread as it is confusing to have multiple threads on the same topic. Thank you.