The results of this poll should be interesting. Having never sailed on Oceania I am curious as to why you consider it in a class by itself. Would love the opportunity to check it out for myself - maybe this year, if I'm lucky.
I have to agree in regards to Oceania, as food, service and amenities (oh, those wonderful beds!) are well ahead of the other premium lines IMHO. Yet, I do not see Oceania winning in the poll, simply because there are much more people going on Celebrity, HAL and Princess.
I don't think there is much of a comparison between Celebrity and Princess, but appreciate the moderator's willingness to accommodate the members of this group. I haven't cruised on Oceania, but it sounds like I should. What is the price difference between Oceania and the other premium lines?
Maybe you should have included four more choices in your Poll Question:
The four other premium cruise lines mentioned by Shibin: Crystal, Raddison, Seabourn, and SilverSea
And how about Cunard?
Unfortunately, I have only been on one cruise in my entire life (Royal Caribn.'s: Sovereign/Seas on Nov.1st-5th last week) so I can't answer this question. All I can say is that I throughly enjoyed the cruise. So, if Celebrity is the luxury version of Royal Caribbean, then Celebrity Cruises would take my vote.