We just got back yesterday from the Western Caribbean on the Navigator. It was all great, only some room for improvement with the food in the Windjammer buffet restaurant. We had a window on the 2nd level, but next time I would request a larger room or a balcany. It's a beautiful ship, great service, the shows were great and if you plan on going, don't miss the ice show. If you're a non-smoker, it's great because they reserve one side of the ship for us.