Having sailed on all three ships, my personal preference would be the "Radiance" out of San Juan. I loved the "Voyage" and enjoyed that trip, but the "Radiance" is a bit classier (my opinion) and a happy compromise between the "Enchantment" and the "Voyager". RCI has taken the best of both and combined them into a wonderful ship that is elegant, stylish, yet loads of fun! It has the rock climbing wall, and miniature golf, but not the ice skating rink of the Voyager. I also like the southern ports a bit better - They are a bit more exotic.