We did the Playa Mia Beach Break last year & thought is was decent. The food was OK, drinks plentiful & it wasn't to crowded until the ferry boat got there at 11 AM & still there was enough room. I've never been to Passion Island but we'll be back to Playa Mia in a few weeks. It's easier to go on your own rather than the ships tour. At least you can go & come as you want & not have to leave when the bus does- Also it saves money.