Mariner (W. Caribbean) vs. Freedom (E. Caribbean)

[MrsPlumb]

Okay - I have a choice to make and it is getting down to the wire. If you had to choose one or the other which trip would you take? Myself, hubby and two 12 yr. old daughters are going, I just can not decide which ship to go on. What would you do?

[Luv2Cruise2007]

Hands down without a doubt or second thought...Go for the Freedom of the Seas. Newer, bigger, better...Although Mariner is an awesome ship but not quite FOS.

[Sonny V]

I'll second that.

Sonny

[MrsPlumb]

so destination would not be what would make you decide one way or the other?

[Chef Ken]

Is it important to you? My opinion is that Eastern Caribbean has much more to offer as destinations and excursions go. If the ship is your destination then you have two opinions above which I have no reason to believe would be anything less than excellent.