My options are Jewel of the Seas going to Aruba, Colon-Panama, Limon-Costa Rica, Cartagena-Colombia & Grand Cayman or Adventure of the Seas out of Puerto Rico to Charlotte Amalie, Basseterre, Aruba & Curacao.

If you've done these, can you tell me which one you prefer?

I'm not concerned about the ship, just the itinerary.

Thanks

Hi joarc, it's really hard to say. Do you want to do the Panama Canal or do you want to do islands? I haven't done the Panama Canal itinerary, yet, but do have it on my bucket list. I have been to Aruba and Grand Cayman. They're both flat island, clean, decent shopping, decent snorkeling. I have done the southern Caribbean and really, really enjoy that itinerary. St. Thomas is a popular stop, very busy island, scenic, good beaches, decent snorkeling. We usually go over to Trunk Bay from there, which is fantastic. St. Kitts is a beautiful island, not overly populated or Americanized. Aruba is a flat island, so not much scenery, but nice beaches and very clean. Curacao is a great island, very colorful, good snorkeling, good shopping, very scenic.

Without knowing what your intersts are, it's hard to say.